Welcome to Sign in | Join | Help
in Search

What's wrong with incentivizing our teachers?

Last post 06-29-2007, 11:36 AM by tscott06. 1 replies.
Sort Posts: Previous Next
  •  06-18-2007, 9:26 PM 414

    What's wrong with incentivizing our teachers?

    I caught this article in the NYTimes today. It reports on an interesting plan to incentivize teachers by tying classroom performance to merit pay. Many oppose it, including unions. What's wrong with incentivizing teachers? Why not encourage them, especially those who think out of the box or care more than others, but feel weighed down by the bureaucracy of the school system? Here's an excerpt and link to the article... you may need to register to read the entire article, FYI

    June 18, 2007

    Long Reviled, Merit Pay Gains Among Teachers

    MINNEAPOLIS — For years, the unionized teaching profession opposed few ideas more vehemently than merit pay, but those objections appear to be eroding as school districts in dozens of states experiment with plans that compensate teachers partly based on classroom performance.

    Here in Minneapolis, for instance, the teachers’ union is cooperating with Minnesota’s Republican governor on a plan in which teachers in some schools work with mentors to improve their instruction and get bonuses for raising student achievement. John Roper-Batker, a science teacher here, said his first reaction was dismay when he heard his school was considering participating in the plan in 2004.

    “I wanted to get involved just to make sure it wouldn’t happen,” he said.

    But after learning more, Mr. Roper-Batker said, “I became a salesman for it.” He and his colleagues have voted in favor of the plan twice by large margins.

    Minnesota’s $86 million teacher professionalization and merit pay initiative has spread to dozens of the state’s school districts, and it got a lift this month when teachers voted overwhelmingly to expand it in Minneapolis. A major reason it is prospering, Gov. Tim Pawlenty said in an interview, is that union leaders helped develop and sell it to teachers.


    I groot about getting past all the bull-doody.
  •  06-29-2007, 11:36 AM 429 in reply to 414

    Re: What's wrong with incentivizing our teachers?

    This, like many other social "fixins" reminds me of baking- if your pie tastes awful, it isn't the oven's or pan's fault, it's the ingredients. Bureaucratized public education doesn't work, because it's bureaucratized and, to some extent, public.

    "Incentivizing" teachers, I think, is pandering and only leads to other avenues for inept managment. Motivating teachers by pay also shifts quality from input to output, which is backwards. You want good out put, you've got to focus on the input,i.e. ingredients.

    Ironic thing is that for an industry in teaching, they seem to not get the most basic of principles.


    There is a certain class of race-problem solvers who do not want the patient to get well, because as long as the disease holds out they have not only an easy means of making a living, but also an easy medium through which to make themselves prominent before the public."
View as RSS news feed in XML